skip to main | skip to sidebar
Subscribe in a reader
Follow FootballBanter on Twitter

English Football Sites

  • Sky Sports Home
  • Football365
  • Live Football Online
  • Football United
  • 4Sportsake
  • Football Talent Spotter
  • ITV Football
  • English Football League
  • Premier League Home
  • UEFA
  • BBC Football

Reuters UK Football News

Loading...

The Premier League Of Blogs

  • Soccerlens.com
    Duke’s Cooper Flagg calls declaring for the 2025 NBA Draft his ‘best decision in hindsight’
    1 day ago
  • WDKF | Qualified Football Arm Chair Managers Slash Pundits
    Hướng dẫn cách xóa tài khoản BK8 đơn giản, nhanh gọn
    6 months ago
  • East Lower
    Winning ugly is beautiful
    9 months ago
  • Inside Left
    Cara Menemukan Jackpot Room Bagus Duofu Duocai
    11 months ago
  • Twohundredpercent
    On writing, self-belief, and overcoming imposter syndrome.
    2 years ago
  • West Ham Till I Die
    Here Comes the Upsetter
    4 years ago
  • The Referee
    kok篮球赛-红蓝后防真核心!11次解围+96%传球准确率,皮克获评8.0分
    4 years ago
  • Sport Is A TV Show
    On the Way - or - Do you believe in magic?
    5 years ago
  • Manchester United blog..
    Nemanja Matic - 'Just what United needed' or 'a bad deal'?
    7 years ago
  • Back Of The Net
    Clubs to introduce sensitivity training for orgies
    10 years ago
  • Gunnerblog
    Video: On the Whistle reaction to Burnley – “They can’t all be pretty”
    10 years ago
  • The Beautiful Game
    Football League seem determined to 'get' Leeds United
    10 years ago
  • The Scottish Football Blog
    Ibrox investment is small change for Ashley
    10 years ago
  • Black & White & Read All Over
    They think it's all over... it is now
    11 years ago
  • Football Transfer
    12 years ago
  • Tarquin Football
    Beat Lawro Retirement
    14 years ago
  • Arseblog
  • AVFC Blog
  • West Ham Fans
  • Chelsea Blog
  • Some People Are On The Pitch
  • Harry Hotspur
  • Heaven Sports» HeavenSports.com
  • Football World Roundup
  • FourFourTwo
  • RLN Football

Labels

  • 'Boro (6)
  • AC Milan (4)
  • Administration (1)
  • African Cup of Nations (1)
  • Alan Curbishley (2)
  • Alan Shearer (1)
  • Alexandre Gaydamak (1)
  • Alisher Usmanov (1)
  • Anderson (1)
  • Andrei Arshavin (5)
  • Andrew Cole (1)
  • Argies (1)
  • Arsenal (15)
  • Arsene Wenger (10)
  • Ashley Cole (1)
  • Ashley Young (1)
  • Aston Villa (8)
  • Australia (2)
  • Avram Grant (2)
  • Awards (2)
  • Bale (1)
  • Ballon d'Or (1)
  • Barcelona (1)
  • BBC (7)
  • Beat Viv (1)
  • Ben Foster (2)
  • Betting (6)
  • Big Phil (9)
  • Big Sam (3)
  • Blackburn (4)
  • Blogging (7)
  • Bobby Moore (1)
  • Bolton (2)
  • Brian Barwick (1)
  • Bruce Buck (1)
  • Captaincy (2)
  • Carling Cup (2)
  • Carlo Ancelotti (1)
  • Carlo Cudicini (2)
  • Carlos Tevez (2)
  • Cesc Fabregas (2)
  • Champions League (18)
  • Cheerleaders (1)
  • Chelsea (27)
  • Chris Woods (1)
  • Christiano Ronaldo (8)
  • Club World Championship (2)
  • Conference League (1)
  • Craig Bellamy (4)
  • Crystal Palace (1)
  • Darren Bent (2)
  • Darren Fletcher (1)
  • David Beckham (7)
  • David Bentley (2)
  • David Dein (1)
  • David James (2)
  • David Moyes (2)
  • David NGog (1)
  • Del Piero (1)
  • Derby County (5)
  • Didier Drogba (4)
  • Diving (1)
  • Dream Team (1)
  • Edwin Van der Saar (3)
  • Eidur Gudjohnsen (1)
  • El Tel (2)
  • El-Hadji Diouf (1)
  • Emile Heskey (1)
  • Emmanuel Adebayor (1)
  • England (25)
  • ESPN (2)
  • EURO 2012 (10)
  • Europa League (1)
  • Everton (2)
  • FA (2)
  • FA Cup (7)
  • Fabio Capello (6)
  • Fantasy Footie (12)
  • Farhad Moshiri (1)
  • Fernando Torres (2)
  • FIFA (14)
  • FIFA World Footballer of the Year (1)
  • Football Records (2)
  • Football Romance (3)
  • FourFourTwo (1)
  • France (3)
  • Frank Lampard (1)
  • Frazier Campbell (1)
  • Fulham (4)
  • Funny Videos (4)
  • Gabriele Abonglahor (1)
  • Gareth Barry (3)
  • Gareth Southgate (1)
  • Gary Neville (2)
  • Gazza (1)
  • General Thread (2)
  • George Gillette Jr (2)
  • Gianfranco Zola (2)
  • Giles Barnes (1)
  • Goalkeepers (1)
  • Guus Hiddink (5)
  • Harry Redknapp (10)
  • Heurehlo Gomes (1)
  • Hull City (8)
  • I'd Love It.... (1)
  • Ian McParland (1)
  • Ian Watmore (1)
  • Ineligible Players (1)
  • Inter Milan (5)
  • Ireland (6)
  • Italy (1)
  • Jaap Stam (1)
  • James Milner (1)
  • James Vaughan (1)
  • Jamie O'Hara (2)
  • January 2009 Transfer Window (27)
  • January 2010 Transfer Window (2)
  • Jermain Defoe (2)
  • Jermaine Jenas (2)
  • Jermaine Pennant (1)
  • Jimmy Bullard (4)
  • Jo (1)
  • Joe Hart (1)
  • Joe Kinnear (1)
  • John Terry (3)
  • Jokes (1)
  • Joleon Lescott (1)
  • Julien Faubert (1)
  • Jurgen Klinsmann (1)
  • Kaka (7)
  • Kasper Schmeichel (1)
  • Kevin Keegan (2)
  • Kevin Nolan (1)
  • LA Galaxy (3)
  • Ladbrokes (2)
  • Lassana Diarra (1)
  • lawro (2)
  • League Cup (1)
  • Lionel Messi (1)
  • Live Blogging (3)
  • Liverpool (27)
  • Louis Saha (1)
  • Luis Boa Morte (1)
  • Luka Modric (1)
  • Macheda (1)
  • Man City (23)
  • Man Utd (36)
  • Maradona (2)
  • Mark Hughes (5)
  • Marseille (1)
  • Martin o'Neil (2)
  • Maxi Rodriguez (1)
  • Mexico (1)
  • Michael Ballack (1)
  • Michael Owen (3)
  • Michel Platini (1)
  • Mick McCarthy (2)
  • Mike Ashley (1)
  • Mind Games (1)
  • MOTD (2)
  • Nani (1)
  • National Football Centre (1)
  • Nemanja Vidic (2)
  • New Zealand (1)
  • Newcastle (9)
  • Nigel Clough (2)
  • Nottingham Forrest (2)
  • Notts County (2)
  • Officials (1)
  • Offside (1)
  • Old Trafford (1)
  • Olivier Dacourt (1)
  • Olympics (1)
  • Owen Hargreaves (1)
  • Oxford United (2)
  • Pascal Chimbonda (2)
  • Paul Scholes (1)
  • Pavlyuchenko (1)
  • Pele (1)
  • Peter Crouch (1)
  • Peter Shilton (1)
  • Petr Cech (1)
  • Polls (7)
  • Portsmouth (6)
  • Portugal (2)
  • Premier League (36)
  • PSV (1)
  • QPR (2)
  • Quiz Answers (1)
  • Quiz Questions (45)
  • Quiz Rules (1)
  • Quota (1)
  • Quotes (1)
  • Rafa Benitez (18)
  • Reading (1)
  • Real Madrid (11)
  • Relegation Battle (7)
  • Ricardo Quaresma (1)
  • Rich Football People (3)
  • Rick Parry (2)
  • Rio Ferdinand (2)
  • Robbie Keane (4)
  • Roberto Mancini (1)
  • Robinho (3)
  • Roma (1)
  • Roman Abramovich (8)
  • Roque Santa Cruz (3)
  • Russia (2)
  • Ruud van Nistelrooy (1)
  • RVP (1)
  • Ryan Babel (1)
  • Ryan Giggs (4)
  • Sackings (1)
  • Saturday Round Up (1)
  • Scorecard (1)
  • Sepp (1)
  • Setanta (3)
  • Shay Given (2)
  • Sheff Utd (2)
  • Sheik Mansour bin Zayed al Nahyan (3)
  • Shirt Sponsors (1)
  • Silvio Berlusconi (1)
  • Sir Alex Ferguson (14)
  • Sir Bobby Robson (1)
  • Sky Sports (5)
  • Sol Campbell (2)
  • South Africa (2)
  • Southend United (1)
  • Spain (3)
  • SPL (1)
  • Stats (2)
  • Steve Clarke (1)
  • Steve Gibson (2)
  • Steve Harper (1)
  • Steve McClaren (2)
  • Steven Gerrard (1)
  • Stewart Downing (2)
  • Stoke (1)
  • Summer 2009 Transfer Window (10)
  • Sunderland (2)
  • Super 6 (24)
  • Sven Goran Eriksson (5)
  • Tarquin (1)
  • The FA (4)
  • The Special One (8)
  • Theo Walcott (1)
  • Thierry Henry (1)
  • Tipping (19)
  • Togo (1)
  • Tom Hicks (2)
  • Tony Adams (1)
  • Tottenham (15)
  • Transfer Rules (1)
  • Tributes (1)
  • Twitter (1)
  • UEFA (5)
  • UEFA Cup (4)
  • USA (3)
  • Wales (1)
  • Watford (1)
  • Wayne Bridge (5)
  • Wayne Rooney (1)
  • Weekend Betting (9)
  • Wembley (1)
  • West Brom (2)
  • West Ham (10)
  • Wigan (3)
  • Wikio (9)
  • William Gallas (1)
  • Wilson Palacios (1)
  • Wolves (1)
  • World Cup 2010 (26)
  • World Cup 2014 (1)
  • World Cup 2018 Bid (2)
  • Xabi Alonso (2)
  • Yakubu (1)
  • Zenit (1)
Wikio - Top Blogs - Sport

Form Book

  • ► 2011 (5)
    • ► October (1)
    • ► August (1)
    • ► June (1)
    • ► March (2)
  • ► 2010 (50)
    • ► October (5)
    • ► September (2)
    • ► August (3)
    • ► May (2)
    • ► April (2)
    • ► March (6)
    • ► February (12)
    • ► January (18)
  • ▼ 2009 (324)
    • ▼ December (19)
      • Oh, you're angry?
      • What Not To Bet - Dan's Super 6
      • Champions League Last 16 Draw
      • Arshavin At Anfield
      • Team selection update: Guess who ees complaining
      • Will Pompey be summoned too?
      • I Agree, Rafa Should Go
      • What The Scores Won't Be... Dan's Super 6
      • Have some free money
      • Time for Benitez to go?
      • Man Utd Selection Crisis
      • Easy?
      • England get USA, Algeria, Slovenia - France get lucky
      • Super 6 Predictions - 05-Dec-09
      • Mandela talks to the world
      • Messi Wins Ballon d'Or
      • Le Injustice!
      • England Seeded
      • FIFA to announce seeding
    • ► November (24)
    • ► October (17)
    • ► September (16)
    • ► August (26)
    • ► July (10)
    • ► June (17)
    • ► May (14)
    • ► April (17)
    • ► March (43)
    • ► February (72)
    • ► January (49)
  • ► 2008 (13)
    • ► December (13)

Directory Enquiries

http://www.wikio.co.uk blogarama - the blog directory British Blogs Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory Bloglisting.net - The internets fastest growing blog directory Blog Flux Directory Soccer (Football) Blog Directory Add to Technorati Favorites

Football Banter

Will Pompey be summoned too?

17 Dec 2009

In tonight's 2-1 defeat to Chelsea, Avram Grant made seven changes to his already-meagre squad from the weekend - albeit a few were enforced, but he still rested a few, such as that well known midfielder Hassan Yebda and Michael Brown

But nevertheless, these were both players who had become first team fixtures in the past months and were not injured, likewise leading scorer Dindane was on the bench - so will the Premier League be asking them to explain themselves?

It is true that "Premier League rule 20, section E, says teams must field a full-strength side in all top-flight matches"

But how exactly do you enforce this rule? Does Rafa get picked up for resting Torres or Gerrard (he started N'gog over Torres this evening)? Does Fergie always have to play Vidic and Rooney when fit, and indeed, the Lord Giggs himself?

I thought the manager was in control of his team - I was not aware that the Premier League issued 'preferred team sheets' to all clubs and sought to discipline a manager for making a tactical decision

Perhaps from a point of view of match fixing I can understand, but considering United already had odds of 1/9 prior to the changed team I found that an unlikely concern in this case

And while there may been ten changes, there were still a few first-team performers, much like how several of the seven at Portsmouth weren't just being rested

For example, one of Wolves best players, Mancienne, started after being on the bench at the weekend, as did league regular Greg Halford, who's been injured, and George Elokobi made his ninth start of the season, as did Castillo - would you question these decisions in any other game? No, so that's already got this figure of 10 down to six

Then there's Chris Iwelumo, who needs no introduction - is he considered a Wolves trainee?

So all in all you can see that there were only five players who you wouldn't expect to be there (and David Edwards picked up a serious injury against Spurs), does anyone at the league have a problem resting Doyle for Iwelumo? Do they regard it as a sin for Mark Hughes to rest Adebayor and Tevez for Santa Cruz and Bellamy?

No, of course they don't, the manager has the right to pick whoever he wants - McCarthy certainly picked a weakened side, but that's a subjective opinion - at least half his squad can be considered first team regulars, while only one player made his debut - George Friend, so he was hardly 'doing an Arsenal'

He rested several key players, just like any other manager who needed his team fit for the weekend would, and he gave a run-out to several deserving players like Mancienne, Halford and Iwelumo - what the league are effectively doing here is disapproving of a manager who uses a bit of rotation (see: Mourinho)

Or rather, what they are doing is passing judgement on Wolves because they don't respect a few of the players fielded, they would never do this if Fergie played Nani, or rested Berba for Owen

I can't say I'm McCarthy's biggest fan, but he made a decent tactical decision -  he's got a weak side as it is and faced playing three league games in a week, when you are facing the reigning champions days before a potential six-pointer against Burnley wouldn't you want to give yourself the best possible chance against Burnley and cut your losses against United? Yes, they might have done a bit better with Craddock, Berra, Stearman, Henry, Jarvis and Doyle on the pitch, but be realistic - Old Trafford the game after United were beaten at home? If they had Arsenal or Chelsea the weekend after maybe, but it's completely sensible to write off the mid-week game when faced with a very good chance a few days later, nobody seriously thinks they stood a chance - I predicted four before I even knew about the team, 3-0 is hardly a travesty at Old Trafford ....it could've been two, big whoop

To be honest I find it quite disrespectful for the league to judge what is and isn't a full strength team - he hardly fielded the under-12s, don't all members of a squad (only one of whom hadn't played before) deserve the occasional run-out?

I will finish my rant with a response:

Wolves supporter chief Arthur Williams - "Hopefully he will pick a full-strength team against Burnley and make amends."

Of course he bloody will, you numptie!... What is the obsession with wanting to see a full-strength side lose at United? Take your blinkers off and look at the bigger picture - it's about 20 miles to the north...

Posted by Tarquin at 00:33:00    

http://www.wikio.co.uk

Labels: Mick McCarthy, Portsmouth, Premier League

1 comments:

Daniel1979 said...

I have to say I agree 100%. In this case with 3 games in a week I would have done exactly the same as Wolves and concentrated on the weekend game against Burnley. As you point out a reasonable team was fielded so travelling fans would not of seen their team just lay down.

It is the role of a club chairman to remove a manager if he is not picking a strong side, not the role of the league. If they had of "done an Arsenal" then I think the fans and Chairman would have a stronger opinion but if they win against Burnley Mick can rightly claim to be justified in his selections.

17 December 2009 at 08:20  

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Blog Design by Gisele Jaquenod

Work under CC License.

Creative Commons License